The safety and efficacy of nimodipine oral solution in the treatment of patients with SAH is based on adequate and well-controlled studies of nimodipine oral capsules in patients with SAH. Nimodipine oral solution has comparable bioavailability to nimodipine oral capsules.
Nimodipine has been shown in 4 randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials to reduce the severity of neurological deficits resulting from vasospasm in patients who have had a recent SAH (Studies 1, 2, 3, and 4).
The trials used doses ranging from 20 to 30 mg to 90 mg every 4 hours, with drug given for 21 days in 3 studies, and for at least 18 days in the other. Three of the four trials followed patients for 3 to 6 months. Three of the trials studied relatively well patients, with all or most patients in Hunt and Hess Grades I to III (essentially free of focal deficits after the initial bleed). Study 4 studied much sicker patients with Hunt and Hess Grades III to V. Studies 1 and 2 were similar in design, with relatively unimpaired SAH patients randomized to nimodipine or placebo. In each, a judgment was made as to whether any late-developing deficit was due to spasm or other causes, and the deficits were graded. Both studies showed significantly fewer severe deficits due to spasm in the nimodipine group; Study 2 showed fewer spasm-related deficits of all severities. No effect was seen on deficits not related to spasm. See Table 2.
Table 2: Deficits in Patients with Hunt and Hess Grades I to III in Study 1 and Study 2
Study
| Grade*
| Treatment
| Patients
|
Number Analyzed
| Number of Patients with Any Deficit Due to Spasm
| Numbers with Severe Deficit
|
Study 1
| I to III
| Nimodipine 20 to 30 mg every 4 hours
| 56
| 13
| 1
|
Placebo
| 60
| 16
| 8**
|
Study 2
| I to III
| Nimodipine 60 mg every 4 hours
| 31
| 4
| 2
|
Placebo
| 39
| 11
| 10**
|
*H *Hunt and Hess Grade
**p=0.03
Study 3 was a 554-patient trial that included SAH patients with all grades of severity (89% were in Hunt and Hess Grades I to III). In Study 3, patients were treated with placebo or 60 mg of nimodipine every 4 hours. Outcomes were not defined as spasm related or not but there was a significant reduction in the overall rate of brain infarction and severely disabling neurological outcome at 3 months (Table 3):
Table 3: Degree of Recovery or Disability in Study 3 (89% Hunt and Hess Grades I to III)
| Nimodipine
| Placebo
|
Total patients
| 278
| 276
|
Good recovery
| 199*
| 169
|
Moderate disability
| 24
| 16
|
Severe disability
| 12**
| 31
|
Death
| 43***
| 60
|
*p = 0.0444 – good and moderate vs severe and dead
** p = 0.001 – severe disability
***p = 0.056 – death
Study 4 enrolled much sicker patients, (Hunt and Hess Grades III to V), who had a high rate of death and
disability, and used a dose of 90 mg every 4 hours, but was otherwise similar to Study 1 and Study 2. Analysis of delayed ischemic deficits, many of which result from spasm, showed a significant reduction in spasm-related deficits. Among analyzed patients (72 nimodipine, 82 placebo), there were the following outcomes (Table 4).
Table 4: Neurological Ischemic Deficits in Study 4 [Hunt and Hess Grades III to V]
| Delayed Ischemic Deficits (DID)
| Permanent Deficits
|
Nimodipine 90 mg every 4 hours
n (%)
| Placebo
n (%)
| Nimodipine 90 mg every 4 hours
n (%)
| Placebo
n (%)
|
DID Spasm Alone
| 8 (11)*
| 25 (31)
| 5 (7)*
| 22 (27)
|
DID Spasm Contributing
| 18 (25)
| 21 (26)
| 16 (22)
| 17 (21)
|
DID Without Spasm
| 7 (10)
| 8 (10)
| 6 (8)
| 7 (9)
|
No DID
| 39 (54)
| 28 (34)
| 45 (63)
| 36 (44)
|
*p = 0.001, Nimodipine vs placebo
When data were combined for Study 3 and Study 4, the treatment difference on success rate (i.e., good recovery) on the Glasgow Outcome Scale was 25.3% (nimodipine) versus 10.9% (placebo) for Hunt and Hess Grades IV or V. Table 5 demonstrates that nimodipine tends to improve good recovery of SAH patients with poor neurological status post-ictus, while decreasing the numbers with severe disability and vegetative survival.
Table 5: Glasgow Outcome Scale in Combined Studies 3 and 4
Glasgow Outcome*
| Nimodipine (n=87)
| Placebo (n=101)
|
Good Recovery
| 22 (25.3%)
| 11 (10.9%)
|
Moderate Disability
| 8 (9.2%)
| 12 (11.9%)
|
Severe Disability
| 6 (6.9%)
| 15 (14.9%)
|
Vegetative Survival
| 4 (4.6%)
| 9 (8.9%)
|
Death
| 47 (54.0%)
| 54 (53.5%)
|
*p = 0.045, nimodipine vs. placebo
A dose-ranging study comparing 30 mg, 60 mg, and 90 mg doses found a generally low rate of spasm-related neurological deficits but no dose response relationship.